Star Wars: Digital vs Film

Written by David Shapton

Disney / Redshark NewsStar Wars: The Force Awakens

Regardless of the decision to shoot Star Wars: The Force Awakens on film, digital video has come a long ways since the premiere of (sub-HD) Episodes II and III.

There's been a lot written about the fact that film was used for the current Star Wars episode, in an apparently backward step from the bold decision to use digital video for Episodes II and III.

But most accounts of this decision are somewhat misleading, implying that film was chosen because digital looks so bad in comparison, specifically with those episodes (II and III) from early in this century.

The problem comes from thinking that digital is digital: the idea that once something's represented in ones and zeros, it's all the same. This is something that we know is manifestly untrue.

Sub-HD Star Wars

The simple fact is that, back then, in 2002, the state of the art in digital cinematography was Sony's F900, which, while it was able to shoot in 24p, used 3:1 compression and only had a native resolution of 1440 x 1080. When it was cropped to the final aspect ratio of 2.35:1, the resulting image was somewhat less than HD. (Read Joe Foster's excellent article on how George Lucas pioneered the use of Digital Video here.)

It's also fair to assume that the dynamic range wasn't as stellar as more modern cameras like the ARRI Alexa or Sony's own F65.

A more apt comparison

So while it may be true that film was chosen because of the general negativity around the look of Episode II, it's absolutely unfair to use this film as any sort of benchmark of what is available today.

Personally, if I wanted a film look, I'd put a Cooke anamorphic on the front of an ARRI Alexa and be very satisfied with the results. And if you want to see the heights to which digital can aspire, just look at Oblivion, shot with a Sony F65.

Tags: Studio & Broadcast

Comments

Related Articles

28 May, 2020

You can now appear in a football stadium from your own home

Conferencing technology will allow fans to both watch the football, and appear as fans in the stadium. 

It might look odd, but you are going to have...

Read Story

4 May, 2020

Alteons Production Ecosystem plans to change Payments for Filmmakers

Many freelancers and indie filmmakers will know the pain of how difficult it can be not knowing when payment will be made for the work they’ve...

Read Story

13 March, 2020

Dolby Vision IQ, a new take on an old feature?

Auto brightness adjustments on televisions are nothing new, but Dolby's Vision IQ is an attempt to make HDR viewing more viable in a wider variety...

Read Story