Beauty or believability: is the effect of CGI in films actually getting worse?

Written by RedShark News Staff

The HulkBeauty or Believability: is CGI actually making films worse?

Is CGI actually making films less convincing?

Computer generated effects have been seen in films for at least a... generation. They started out small and have grown to the point where the entire screen is CGI, including live-action from the actors, via motion capture.

Here's a video that talks about how some of the early effects were more effective, despite being less - how shall we say this - accomplished. The theory proposed in the film is that while early effects might not have been so good, they used natural backgrounds, and so kept the viewer grounded in reality.

As CGI has grown to take in an entire film set, so has believability diminished.

And then there's the Uncanny Valley: the apparently genuine consequence of being in the presence of a CGI human that is so close to being real that it makes us feel uneasy.

This is a good exploration of these issues. Some of the reasoning is on slightly shaky ground, we feel (some of the examples are cherry picked) and the data supporting the arguments is does not prove cause and effect - but it's a good exposition. Well worth watching.


Tags: Post & VFX


Related Articles

27 July, 2020

LaCie 1big Dock SSD Pro and 1big Dock: Your storage media is now an important connectivity hub [Sponsored]

When is storage not simply storage? Today’s storage is now becoming a highly important connectivity hub to help speed up your workflows.

The LaCie...

Read Story

18 July, 2020

The Quantel name is legendary. This is its story, and ultimately what happened to it

The story of Quantel is a classic story of the rise and fall of a high-end manufacturer with a groundbreaking product based on very expensive,...

Read Story

16 July, 2020

Is colour grading essential? Perhaps we are too obsessed with it

The current consensus is that the best practice for shooting is to aim for the maximum options in post. So we shoot in log, or maybe RAW, to give us...

Read Story