27 Jan 2017

Should you 3D print your camera accessories?

  • Written by 
  • submit to reddit  
Ursa Mini 4.6K with Nikon series E 100mm lens and 3D printed gear Ursa Mini 4.6K with Nikon series E 100mm lens and 3D printed gear RedShark News

Index

Free 3D models of camera accessories are readily available. But does it really now make sense to 3D print your own lens gears?

Some of the flakiest bits of engineering currently being inflicted on filmmaking are those horrible wraparound lens gears. Some are better than others, but you know what I mean - the flexible plastic strip which slips in the middle of a difficult and otherwise impeccably-executed setup, preferably one involving a pyrotechnics with a five-hour reset time.

Times like those are the ones that everyone thinks look like an absolute blast on the behind-the-scenes footage, but in reality involve a lot of people running around checking things, gnawing their fingers down to the bone in case their department is afflicted with the sort of SNAFU which will make the people from all the other departments glare at them.

And then the follow focus equipment falls apart.

All right, there will be no further hyperbole and, we should admit (through our teeth) that circumstances exist in which we have to find a way to connect a focus motor to a randomly-selected lens. In fact, the cheaper and nastier the lens, the more likely it is to have a tiny focus rotation, so that the ability to gear it down electronically becomes evermore crucial. There are a number of very reliable solutions to this problem, from ground-up rehousing in an entirely new metal shell, through custom gear machining services. The problem is that all of these things involve significant expense and significant lead time, which, in 2017, pushes us towards the realisation that it's possible to make lens gears using a 3D printer.

Gears on demand?

Nikon_Series_E_100mm_lens_with_3D_printed_gear.JPGNikon Series E 100mm lens with 3D printed gear

It is, to be fair, only just possible to make lens gears using the type of deposition printers that are most common at the moment. Regardless of their claims to precision, squirting molten plastic out of a nozzle is a technique capable of accuracy which would embarrass a real machinist. The shape of cinema lens gear teeth created using this technique is on the very borders of usability. The key is that it's possible to print a gear that has an internal diameter very close to that of the relevant external diameter on the lens, so it's actually possible to attach them pretty securely.

The lenses shown here are from Nikon's low-cost Series E, products of the early 80s. While Nikon pointedly withheld the Nikkor branding from these, changing times mean they're actually better built than a lot of modern autofocus lenses. As cinematography devices, they suffer short focus rotation (though again, not as short as some modern glass) and only match tolerably well, but as a low-cost way to own a set of primes that can ride on a speed booster, they're not a terrible option. Also, the focus grips are the largest diameter parts, when approached from the camera end of the lens, so it's possible to slide focus gears into place without doing any disassembly. This is generally not the case on the commonly-used Nikkor AIs lenses, where the mechanical aperture interface must be removed, but it isn't rocket science.

Setting_up_a_gear_in_Sketchup.pngSetting up a gear in Sketchup

Even on a quality deposition printer, creating perfectly aligned friction-fit parts like this is still not entirely push-button. These particular lenses have slightly compressible rubber grips, so it's possible to ease things into place, but each of these gears needed minor manual finishing (keep the shavings away from the lenses) to finalise their fit. The result is very encouraging. Is it as good as a properly-machined gear? Of course not, but it's vastly cheaper, much more available and a full light year ahead of the strap-on flexible strip. There's a bit of ingenuity required with the software, but these gears won't fall off or rotate against the lens barrel, at least with any amount of force that doesn't just threaten to break either the plastic or the lens itself.

Ultimaker_2_hard_at_work_printing_a_gear.pngUltimaker 2 hard at work printing a gear

For camera equipment, there is a need for this sort of engineering. Mounts for odd pieces of equipment are an obvious target. While it probably isn't a good idea to try and create an entire rod-mounting mattebox and follow focus system from the ABS plastic used in these printers, someone has, of course, done it anyway. Better technology, such as laser-cured resins, can offer better precision and, frankly, more professionally-acceptable results from a cosmetic point of view. In extremis, we could raise concerns about whether the slightly uneven gear surface would create noise during fast focus pulls and whether a real, expensive follow focus gear might be scarred by interfacing with the rougher printed option. So far, these concerns seem to be largely theoretical.



« Prev |


Phil Rhodes

Phil Rhodes is a Cinematographer, Technologist, Writer and above all Communicator. Never afraid to speak his mind, and always worth listening to, he's a frequent contributor to RedShark.

Twitter Feed