13 Feb 2017

Is Intel in danger of becoming irrelevant?

  • Written by 
  • submit to reddit  
Intel may be feeling pressure from all sides. Intel may be feeling pressure from all sides. Intel / RedShark News


The AMD Factor

AMD's influence here actually cuts both ways. Intel's GPUs, in spite of their improvements, still rate pretty low on the computing totem pole. But AMD's main processors are still pretty thoroughly outclassed by Intel's.

AMD is hoping to address the latter with Ryzen, which looks to be competitive with Intel's desktop processors, based on the initial demos and benchmarks. If AMD is able to capture significant market share from Intel, consumers might finally get to benefit from the competition again; Intel would likely end up lowering prices and also step up to the plate with more aggressive designs once more.

Significantly more bizarre is the possibility that Intel and AMD might also be striking an alliance. Hardware website HardOCP is pretty confident about its source, but until AMD and Intel go public one way or another, the fact that Intel might start incorporating AMD GPUs into its processors, replacing its own mediocre GPUs with AMD's much more powerful GPUs, is just a rumour, albeit a rather interesting one.

The MIC Factor

One of the traits that makes GPUs such a problem for Intel is that modern ones incorporate huge numbers of simple processors that are optimized for computing oriented tasks. Intel's attempt to match these has been its Many Integrated Cores (MIC) processors, sold under the Xeon Phi brand. These are based on simplified versions of Intel's P54C core, with higher clock speeds and the SkyLake FPU, including the new Fused Multiply-Add instruction. With current models sporting in the realm of 200 such cores, on the surface they're not in the same league as nVidia's Pascal GPUs. Core counts don't tell the entire story, however; each core in a Pascal can run one instruction at a time on one piece of data, so a group masquerades as a single SIMD processor, while the cores in Xeon Phi can execute SIMD instructions natively. Rather than being outclassed by orders of magnitude, Xeon Phi is only outclassed by a factor of two or three.

Intel is counting on being able to achieve a higher utilization for the cores in Xeon Phi, enabling developers to use a higher percentage of the Xeon Phi's peak performance than most will be able to get with a Pasacal, thus leveling the playing field to some extent. How well this will work remains to be seen, but initial results show some promise, since there are some Top 500 supercomputers built using Xeon Phi.

Since the current Xeon Phi models can host a full operating system, it's possible that we'll start seeing workstations based on Xeon Phi on the market. These could be combined with powerful GPUs, but it's unlikely that Xeon Phi will offer as much single-threaded performance as contemporary Core or Zen processors, making a Core or Zen a better choice as the host processor. The high single-threaded performance combined with a large number of compute cores provides system balance; tasks that are parallizable can be executed on the massively parallel GPU, while tasks that do not parallelize well can be executed on the fast host processor with small number of cores.

In other words, Xeon Phi is a niche product.

What's next for Intel?

So, what will Intel's next move be? For the near term, Intel's most likely plan is to continue developing x86 processors and, if Ryzen is competitive enough, it might force Intel to lower its prices as well as to step up development of new processors. Both of these would be good for consumers, but it's very likely that GPUs will continue to overshadow the host processors, which will force Intel and AMD both to lower their prices.

With the lower end of Intel's market getting eaten away by mobile processors, higher end sales shrinking and AMD getting back in the game, it might seem as if Intel's days of dominance are numbered. It definitely seems as if x86's dominance in personal computing is starting to fade, though it's not really threatened yet in the still lucrative server industry.

It's a sure bet that Intel is aware of the potential in ARM-based servers, as well as the declining sales in the consumer market. Intel is probably also keeping a close eye on Ryzen and, most likely, already has plans underway to keep its future secure.

What those plans are is an open question. Intel hasn't always been particularly successful in branching out in the past; it's tried to get into GPUs several times, never with much success outside of simply giving the GPU away. It's also been very unsuccessful at getting its products into phones and tablets for the most part, with Surface being the only exception so far.

The feeling is that something has to give. But what? It's going to be an interesting few months ahead.

Rakesh Malik

Rakesh’s exploration into photography began with a trip to the Grand Canyon. The grandeur of the place inspired him to capture and share his experiences. Such grand places required a grand vision, so Rakesh began working with large format film cameras, which he continues to favor for his fine art stills. His love of travel and adventure have lead Rakesh to visit exotic and varied places, from cities such as Kiev and Ronda to wild places like the Serengeti, the Alaskan tundra, the Pampas of Patagonia, and even to lofty heights such as the summits of Mounts Kilimanjaro and Rainier. Lately, in spite of continuing to make captivating still images with film and digital cameras, Rakesh has been applying his photographic skills to motion pictures. While still striving to convey a story with each individual frame, he longer has the limitation of being bound to a single form to tell the story.


Website: aliencraneproductions.com

Twitter Feed