Here's why you sometimes need noise

Written by RedShark News Staff

HDRInstantNoise vs Banding

Noise isn't always the worst thing. Sometimes it can improve your images.

 Have a look at the picture above. It's in two halves. The left half is noisy, but there's very little banding in the blue sky. The right half has less noise, but is heavily banded. Which do you prefer? Some people would prefer the noisy one.

We should say here that this picture was taken for a very different reason - to illustrate some very clever software that takes consecutive video frames and superimposes them to give you a higher dynamic range still frame. That's what happened here. The product is called HDRinstant and you can read about it here.

It does seem to work and you might want to give it a try. But while the picture on the right might have more detail in it as a result of the HDR process, it has less noise as well.

And that means that whereas on the left side, there's no visible banding - but some visible noise - on the left side, there's quite visible banding and very little noise. And it's the lack of noise that causes the problem, because the noise puts enough "randomness" in the picture to smudge the boundaries of the contour lines of the blue sky. They're still there but they're a much more complicated shape because of the noise.

This is just a quick, opportunistic note to point this out as a result of seeing this picture. You don't normally get to see this type of comparison in such stark terms.

But remember: before you write off any of your equipment because it's "only" 8 bit - if you add a bit of noise (or maybe you've got just enough coming off the sensor) then it can look as smooth as 10 bit, if you can only live with the extra graininess.

 

Tags: Technology

Comments

Related Articles

8 July, 2020

LTO tape gets another lease of life, but the search for ultimate archive goes on

The search for a future-proof archive media takes in everything from SSDs to nano-sized quartz, but a breakthrough is happening in the world of tape.

Read Story

6 July, 2020

Sony's new plans could pave the way for software upgradable image sensors

Sony is moving away from hardware based data analysis to a software based subscription approach. The implications could be profound.

Image: ...

Read Story

3 July, 2020

Frame.io: What is the future for remote workflows?

Frame.io’s online Workflow From Home series, hosted by the company’s Global SVP of Innovation, Michael Cioni, has been a definitive look into how to...

Read Story