RedShark Summer Replay: What Colour is Night?

Written by Phil Rhodes

RedSharkWhat Colour is Night?

Redshark's only 10 months old, and our readership is growing all the time. So if you're a new arrival here you'll have missed some great articles from earlier in the year

These RedShark articles are too good to waste! So we're re-publishing them one per day for the next two weeks, under the banner "RedShark Summer Replay".

Here's today's Replay:

 

What Colour is Night?

What colour is night? This simple question leads to some deeper questions about colour in film making.

This is the sort of question that vexes film and TV people because we're torn between two things: the need to follow conventions, so that the audience can follow what's going on, and the desire to be original. Or, to put it another way, we're a bunch of insecure fashion victims who lack the courage of our own convictions.

To be fair, as the excellent and hilarious TV Tropes website puts it, conventions in filmmaking have a purpose, in the same way that traditional storytelling repeatedly turns up the same characters and situations. Traditionally, or at least for decades, movies have rendered night as blue. The prototypical example of this, if not quite the earliest, was the first Terminator film, and since then we've increasingly found movies turning blue and orange. Websites dedicated to identifying examples of this trend exist (such as this 2010 example: http:/theabyssgazes.blogspot.co.uk/2010/03/teal-and-orange-hollywood-please-stop.html).

Unconvincing

Accusations of unconvincing self-tan aside, it's pretty easy to understand what's really going on here: human skin is, with famous variability, some sort of brown. Brown is arguably a desaturated orange, and our traditional sources of light – fire, incandescent light, and the sun at sunset – are also warm in hue. Assuming night is blue, or perhaps teal, we've then achieved production design that fulfils a design guideline familiar to any first-year art student, because the two key colours in the frame are opposite each other on a colour wheel, 180 degrees separated by hue.

Now we know why Bumblebee is the key transformer in Transformers: they love him because he's yellow. When was the last time you saw a green robot in a Michael Bay film? Complainers such as the website above frequently cite colour grading as the core evil, but of course there's far more to production design than that and most of it isn't even technical. If you want the frame to look teal and orange, shoot teal and orange subjects.

This concept of colour separation is basic because it's old, and it's therefore an idea that's probably not going anywhere, notwithstanding widespread accusations of excess. So what colour is night really? Well, traditionally it's blue, possibly because moonlight is really just reflected sunlight, and bluer than most of the other sorts of light which exist at night. Shoot a sufficiently long exposure in moonlight, taking into account reciprocity failure if you're shooting film or noise if you're working electronically, and you will discover that it looks exactly like sunlight.

The colour of night

In a lot of situations in which humans operate after dark, it's lit by incandescent light, which is slightly orange, or sodium vapour light, which is extremely orange. Physiologically, the human eye is most sensitive in the green, so green objects tend to look brightest at night, although in very low light we see mainly in black and white. So, night is either blue, orange, green, or monochrome, or most accurately, in natural conditions, it's exactly the same colour as daytime.

Next week, black is white.

Tags: Post & VFX

Comments

Related Articles

27 July, 2020

LaCie 1big Dock SSD Pro and 1big Dock: Your storage media is now an important connectivity hub [Sponsored]

When is storage not simply storage? Today’s storage is now becoming a highly important connectivity hub to help speed up your workflows.

The LaCie...

Read Story

18 July, 2020

The Quantel name is legendary. This is its story, and ultimately what happened to it

The story of Quantel is a classic story of the rise and fall of a high-end manufacturer with a groundbreaking product based on very expensive,...

Read Story

16 July, 2020

Is colour grading essential? Perhaps we are too obsessed with it

The current consensus is that the best practice for shooting is to aim for the maximum options in post. So we shoot in log, or maybe RAW, to give us...

Read Story